Wednesday, December 12, 2012

Hitting a Special Low

I'm taking a day off of my 2012 Advent Challenge to share about a difficult challenge that we were presented with recently.  Our lives hit a 'special low' last week.  I got a phone call from the director of Peter's collaborative program that they were filing a 51a because of scratches that Peter had on his face.

In case you don't know what a 51a is...it's a report to the Department of Social Services about possible neglect or abuse.  It makes me want to throw up just writing the words.

Why did Peter have scratches?  Just in case you're a new reader, Peter has autism.  Not high functioning autism either.  He is 11 with the cognitive function of a young preschooler.  Peter likes to get a rise out of people.  His newest "game" is to put his face inches away from Luke(our 3 yo) when Luke's watching tv or playing on the floor and then call his name in a very annoying and teasing way so that Luke screams and tries to hit or scratch Peter, which Peter loves and laughs maniacally while Luke is hitting him.  We have been, and continue to, put Luke in time out for hurting and put Peter in his room for instigating.  Peter is obsessed with getting that reaction out of Luke so, as soon as I'm making dinner, or nursing the baby, or putting away laundry, he sticks his face near Luke again.

Easily explained.  If you ask Peter who scratched his face he always says, "Luke" and than laughs.  Scratches on Peter's face have happened a few times over the past 3 weeks.  I had been telling the teachers when it happened and what was going on.

But that't not the way the law works.  The nurse at school confronted the teacher.  And the teacher had no choice but to report it or jeopardize her job.

The kicker is that the teacher knows and believes that the scratches were caused by Luke.  But she has to protect herself because the nurse pressed the issue.  Report it to the state...that's the procedure...that's the "rules"...

And there's nothing I can do about it.  Because that's the law.  No common sense used...no simple questions to find out the truth...just report it to the state.

What about the family and what they go through and the pain and anguish it causes them?  

One of the things the director said to me when she called to let me know that they were filing was, "Don't worry, it's kept private.  No one else will know so other people won't be thinking that you are "one of those parents.""

One of "those parents"....you mean a parent who has been wrongfully accused of hurting their child!?!

I have nothing to hide.  I would venture to say that most parents deal with moments when their children get physical with each other.  Bumps and bruises among siblings are fairly commonplace.  

So does that mean that now, since Kate is entering into a biting phase, that I need to make sure that she is never around Peter for fear that if she bites him....here comes another 51a?  What about the scab on his face that he keeps picking at?  Does that mean another 51a?

I can't keep Peter in a bubble to make sure that he never gets hurt.  And I feel like we are under a microscope that will send someone running to the state to cover their butt every time they see a bump or bruise!

How is that fair?

How am I supposed to parent feeling like someone is always looking over my shoulder?  I feel like every word and every action will be picked apart.  I am second guessing everything, worrying about being scrutinized by people that know nothing about me but will come to judge me and my ability to parent.

It's a horrible feeling.

I guess I can only speak for myself...maybe it wouldn't really bother some families?  I don't know.

I do know that I can't stop crying about it.  I know that I feel so frustrated because I am powerless to change anything or protect my family from it happening again.  (Except maybe by keeping Luke or Peter attached to my hip to make sure there is no rough housing!  Yeah, that's realistic!?!)

I know that my anxiety and fear are at very unhealthy levels.  I know that I will never be able to truly relax again with the school Peter is at....there will always be some level of worry.  My relationship with his teachers and the director of the program will never be the same again, either.  I have always felt that we were a team working for Peter....now I just feel like it's us against the world.

My knee jerk reaction is to yank him out of the school.  Unfortunately, this is the first time in 3 years that he is actually having a really good year.  So do I take him out of that environment and drop him somewhere else mid-year?  Is that fair to him?

I honestly don't know if I can make it through the year, though.  I have resolved to not make any decisions until this has passed and the dust has settled a bit.  It's just so hard:(

I just feel so discouraged....

I have to say that our sped director was very kind...and the director of our home therapy services and Peter's home therapist have been very supportive and willing to back us up completely.  A woman from a special DMR program that Peter was involved with for a year has been very supportive as well...even though his participation in the program ended in September.  I'm grateful for their support and the encouragement of our friends and family.  I'm grateful that after speaking to people involved in Peter's life, especially the director of his home therapy, that the state found no reason to open a formal investigation.

But it still sucks to have to go through this.

Raising a child with special needs, and all the extra sacrifices it takes, can be exhausting.  Parents of special needs kids need all the support we can get.  Being reported falsely and living in the atmosphere where we have to fear being reported again for easily explained incidences does not make our lives easier.

We already live life hard....we don't need the people that should be supporting us to make life harder.

Comments (26)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
XOXOXOXOX.......you and Jay are wonderful parents!!! It takes VERY special people to raise a large family AND a child with special needs, God definately chose the right ones :)
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
I understand having the law in place for when abuse really is occurring but I wish that nurse and teacher could have talked rationally about what kind of family you were, what's been causing the scratches and decided that it wasn't worth reporting. What heartache you must have! I feel bad when my boys have bruises all over their legs when we go to the doctor, I can't imagine if that doctor would claim we were abusing them. And to think of how many innocent children actually are being abused and neglected that never gets reported. It's a tough situation. I hope it's all over now since you're writing about it. HUGS!!
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
How, how your heart must be breaking! I remember when I was 8 I broke both my wrists 3 days apart. One in a roller skating accident and the other when playing in the back yard - bizarre, but it happened. My mom got grilled at the hospital and I was asked detailed questions about how it happened and if anyone did something to me. It was awful and my mom was completely traumatized. Ugh. I'm so sorry you're dealing with this. :-(
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
I'm so sorry that you have to go through this! You were upfront with the teacher about what happened, your son even says the same thing- ugh. I get that they think there is some sort of obligation there, but they need to look at the circumstances!
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
A lot of people with special needs kids actually get reported to the state for false charges. I was reading about this somewhere a few months ago. i forget the exact statsitics but its high.

Years ago we went through something similar and it has forever changed how I view the world. Then we had a sort of repeat of it from the school as well...i really don't trust a lot of people anymore especially those that are at schools and such places since they are mandated reporters of abuse--when typically there is no abuse its just protocol. But they don't realize how that protocol affects the innocent.

yes-if I were you I would be very upset.
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
mary duperre's avatar

mary duperre · 642 weeks ago

So sorry you had to live through that. :( I have never been reported for anything but doctors have asked my kids if they have been abused. it's nuts!

I can tell you that you and Jay amaze me, you are soo patient with your children, you are good parents and that's why God blessed you with all your children :) That's why I want Jacob in the youth group, ( wish he would go) He could learn so much from Jay. Again I am sorry, take care of yourself. May God Bless you and give you peace. :)
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
Michelle, my heart goes out to you and your family. This is just ludicrous! Too bad you don't have a lot of options. I would definitely FEEL like taking my kid out of a school where the teachers and or nurses have no common sense! I am sure that I speak for a lot of people who know you. We are in awe of you and Jay and all that you do. We know what great parents you both are.
1 reply · active 642 weeks ago
I am surprised the nurse had such a knee jerk reaction. I have worked in daycare for the past 12 years and don't usually make such quick judgements before filing 51As. It makes you wonder if it is cases like yours that are bogging down the system making it impossible for them to give their attention to the cases that need it.

I hope that you can work through things with the director and teachers at the school.
1 reply · active 641 weeks ago
I'm so sorry to hear that! When I was working in Day Care years ago, I had a mother wrongfully accuse me of hurting her child. She was after money (more accurately, free child care from the place I worked) and she saw her child fall in my presence and turned it into "she pushed my child". I was 19, I think, at the time. It was a horrible feeling knowing I was innocent, but my boss (who also believed me) had to report it. The case was quickly thrown out, character letters were written on my behalf, I was able to keep my job (though I did transfer to another area of the Day Care working with younger kids, actually) and there were no more false reports. The mother even brought her kid to be WITH ME the day AFTER she filed her complaint proving she didn't even believe the lie she tried to sell. Such a very sad story. She almost ruined my life out of a pursuit of extra cash (she admitted this to her cousin whom I worked with later). Insanity for sure. At any rate, my heart goes out to you and I hope this clears up soon! *hugs to you*
3 replies · active 641 weeks ago
Sandy Holmes's avatar

Sandy Holmes · 641 weeks ago

Michelle.....there are no words to express my sorrow that you of all families had to go through this. I loathed being a mandated reporter and NEVER took it as lightly as that nurse seemed to. The system is so messed up and so abused in and of itself. True abusers get off scott free and the innocent have to go through the a horrific experience. I always felt that it was such a tragedy that those who are supposed to be supportive of folks and families so often turned out to inflict the most pain. Again I'm so very sorry. You know how much I respect and appreciate the awesome way you are raising your wonderful family! Sandy
1 reply · active 641 weeks ago
I'm so sorry that you're going through all of that. It be so hard to parent when our children have special needs, and the teachers (or nurse in this case) don't see eye to eye with the parents. It's need to be a team effort. Not one that breaks up the team. Hang in there!
1 reply · active 641 weeks ago
God bless your courage towrite this blog! I found your blog through women of grace blog with johnette benkovic. Your stories are so uplifting to me. We just had our fifth baby ( actually, 6th. Our first was stillborn at38 1/2 weeks.) Andtruly, I've never suffered with anxiety before now. It's better than itwas in October when it started, but tonight t started in again. Lately, it's just at night when im falling asleep. When i read your days` journey and life`s struggles it makes me feel better knowing im not alone inthis journey of motherhood.
1 reply · active 640 weeks ago

Post a new comment

Comments by